Revisiones de 1Password: Gestor de contraseñas
1Password: Gestor de contraseñas por 1Password Devs
Revisado por Usuario de Firefox 17051350
Se valoró con 3 de 5
por Usuario de Firefox 17051350, hace 5 añosI wrote a frustrated review to start but deleted that with my new understandings that might help first-timers like me.
First, this doesn't automatically make your passwords better or accounts safer. All this does is remember your bad old passwords. You have to manually go in and change all the passwords. As in, go to every site one at a time, go to your account, go to "change password" and then have 1P come up with a new password that you manually copy and paste. It'll remember the password, but you're doing most of the groundwork which seems like it will take a long time. Second, you can help it get started by downloading your saved passwords from your browser then uploading them into the 1P site. Still, it's just remembering your old, crappy password and not doing anything on it's own to make your accounts more secure until you go through the sites, one by one, updating them with the random password 1P generates. And if you're like me, that's a lot of sites. Third, I still haven't figured out how to get into, say, my email account if I'm not home or using a public computer. If I get 1P to change my password to some random letters and numbers to make it safe--great! But then when I need to check my email on a friend's computer, how do I do that? I'm seeing some things about 1P Anywhere but haven't gotten anything definitive yet. So keep that in mind if that's important for you.
First, this doesn't automatically make your passwords better or accounts safer. All this does is remember your bad old passwords. You have to manually go in and change all the passwords. As in, go to every site one at a time, go to your account, go to "change password" and then have 1P come up with a new password that you manually copy and paste. It'll remember the password, but you're doing most of the groundwork which seems like it will take a long time. Second, you can help it get started by downloading your saved passwords from your browser then uploading them into the 1P site. Still, it's just remembering your old, crappy password and not doing anything on it's own to make your accounts more secure until you go through the sites, one by one, updating them with the random password 1P generates. And if you're like me, that's a lot of sites. Third, I still haven't figured out how to get into, say, my email account if I'm not home or using a public computer. If I get 1P to change my password to some random letters and numbers to make it safe--great! But then when I need to check my email on a friend's computer, how do I do that? I'm seeing some things about 1P Anywhere but haven't gotten anything definitive yet. So keep that in mind if that's important for you.
Respuesta del desarrollador
publicado el hace 5 añosHey there,
Thank you for taking the time to write this review!
Yes, 1Password is a tool designed to store and manage all of your passwords. And no, it will not automatically or automagically change all of your passwords for all of your accounts because that’s not (currently) possible, since every website is built and designed differently, but not only that, it would also be an extremely intrusive and privacy-breaking action that we most certainly will not be comfortable offering! Our users’ privacy is extremely important to us :)
The transition to a password manager is not always an easy one. When you start with 1Password it will let you know how many websites and passwords from your list are weak or compromised, and you will need to go into each website and create a strong new password to improve your security. But once you’re done with that initial transition phase, you will be good to go and know that you are oh so much safer online! Not only that, you will never find yourself in the same situation again because 1Password will be there to generate strong passwords automatically for you from now on.
As for your question - if you have specific accounts or services that you would like to be able to log into without 1Password’s help, it is best to generate a strong memorable worded password for that website/service. That way you will be able to memorize it and log into it on any device. Simply open 1Password’s generator and change it from “Random passwords” to “Worded passwords”, or generate them here instead: https://1password.com/password-generator/?type=memorable
If you have further questions or require assistance with anything, do email us to support@1password.com and we’ll be happy to help!
Thank you for taking the time to write this review!
Yes, 1Password is a tool designed to store and manage all of your passwords. And no, it will not automatically or automagically change all of your passwords for all of your accounts because that’s not (currently) possible, since every website is built and designed differently, but not only that, it would also be an extremely intrusive and privacy-breaking action that we most certainly will not be comfortable offering! Our users’ privacy is extremely important to us :)
The transition to a password manager is not always an easy one. When you start with 1Password it will let you know how many websites and passwords from your list are weak or compromised, and you will need to go into each website and create a strong new password to improve your security. But once you’re done with that initial transition phase, you will be good to go and know that you are oh so much safer online! Not only that, you will never find yourself in the same situation again because 1Password will be there to generate strong passwords automatically for you from now on.
As for your question - if you have specific accounts or services that you would like to be able to log into without 1Password’s help, it is best to generate a strong memorable worded password for that website/service. That way you will be able to memorize it and log into it on any device. Simply open 1Password’s generator and change it from “Random passwords” to “Worded passwords”, or generate them here instead: https://1password.com/password-generator/?type=memorable
If you have further questions or require assistance with anything, do email us to support@1password.com and we’ll be happy to help!
1782 revisiones
- Se valoró con 1 de 5por Usuario de Firefox 13261523, hace 9 días1Password does several things well, especially in Google Chrome. However, in Firefox, the 1Password experience is genuinely problematic and highly unreliable.
The most serious issue is that it does not work properly with HTTP Basic Authentication pop-up login windows. In Firefox, I often have to click multiple times and even navigate back in the browser before eventually receiving a different error message, after which the login may finally work. This issue does not occur in Google Chrome.
This has been going on for months. I pay for an expensive subscription, but I do not expect to renew it unless this problem is properly resolved. For my work, I use a very large number of HTTP Basic Authentication links with login pop-ups, and this simply has to function correctly. At the moment, I am forced to click repeatedly or switch to Google Chrome just to get basic functionality.
Support from 1Password has also been extremely slow. It often takes several days to receive a response, which is very disappointing.
My subscription runs until November 2026, but I am already considering alternatives. That is unfortunate, because 1Password does many things very well. However, when it comes to Firefox, the overall experience has been a major disappointment. Judging by the large number of negative comments here, I am clearly not the only one experiencing this.
Sidenote: also the 1Password application for Android phone has issues; it reports 9 out of 10 times, that it has no connection, so all passwords I am adding, do not show up on my desktop. #fail #1password - Se valoró con 1 de 5por Usuario de Firefox 19822537, hace 10 díasThe plugin is significantly slowing my browser, tested my suspicions on a browser benchmark site and speed score went from 8 with the plugin on and 30 with it disabled (nothing else changed)
- Se valoró con 1 de 5por aaFn, hace un mesCrap application, intrusive, pop ups all the time. Obscure ways to configure, tries to be "intelligent" but of course is not and then hides its internal "guessed" configuration, much less flexible and customizable than Keepass.
When imposed by companies, have to use it, else avoid like hell ! (and do not use it for personal side, your data is on a cloud and a company which is not trustable !) - Se valoró con 1 de 5por Usuario de Firefox 5951631, hace un mesIf you already have 1password account, that has some kind of order, this extension will ruin the order you created by duplicating records you created with records called "Sign in" or something.
- Se valoró con 4 de 5por Garett, hace un mesWorks well for the most part, but it can get annoying when I don't want to save a particular account used for log-ins. The pop-up should have a "No, and don't ask me again" option so that it doesn't come up every time.
- Se valoró con 5 de 5por Usuario de Firefox 19433288, hace 2 meses
- Se valoró con 3 de 5por Liang, hace 2 mesesIt works but introduces severe performance degradation, you can prove this by going on browserbench and running the test with it disabled and compare
- Se valoró con 1 de 5por syldub, hace 2 mesesNul. Intrusif au possible. Je dois utiliser 1Password car mon entreprise l'impose... mais KeePass est largement plus adapté. On a sans arrêt des popup au cours de la navigation. Dommage, les options qui auraient pu être intéressantes pour être moins pollué ne sont pas paramétrables. Insupportable. Désinstallé direct.
- Se valoró con 4 de 5por Usuario de Firefox 19025062, hace 3 mesesdescent add-on. Please add a mobile compatible version!
- Se valoró con 4 de 5por mokidokie, hace 3 mesesI've used this for years with no problems, but recently (within the last few months) it's been hyper-aggressive with the pop-up prompts - even when not signed in. Click out of it and immediately it comes back when you focus on the next field on the same page. It's gotten so bad I've had to disable the extension until the time i actually need it, and then once i'm done i have to disable it again. Not sure what the heck they changed on the back end but it needs to stop.
- Se valoró con 5 de 5por Tracy, hace 3 meses
- Se valoró con 1 de 5por Usuario de Firefox 18575225, hace 3 meses
- Se valoró con 4 de 5por Nikola, hace 3 mesesIt works good in most of the time, but sometimes it doesn't. Mostly when it comes to OTP it could make mistakes, and also auto-fill sometimes won't work. But it's ok overall..
- Se valoró con 3 de 5por alexzm1, hace 4 mesesWorks Ok for most of the web sites but it is buggy and doesn't work if I try to use my access key to login in account.samsung.com, it works for other browsers like Chrome and Safari but not in Firefox
- Se valoró con 5 de 5por sharxx47, hace 4 meses
- Se valoró con 5 de 5por DonCan94, hace 4 meses
- Se valoró con 5 de 5por Niels, hace 5 meses
- Se valoró con 1 de 5por Tiago, hace 5 meses1password is great, but this extension - omg.
This is true for all extensions actually, including mobile.
It will just assume that you want to use 1password for everyfield: name? age? postcode? etc... the 1password autocomplete will hijack, hide buttons, misbehave when arrows are being pressed for the default/browser values, etc...
It's the most annoying thing - you have to chose: have a good password completion experience and a terrible for everything else form related? Or the inverse? - Se valoró con 5 de 5por versita, hace 6 meses
- Se valoró con 5 de 5por Usuario de Firefox 19526320, hace 6 meses
- Se valoró con 1 de 5por Arajin, hace 6 mesesHorrible!!
I had to change password manager because of lastpass not being able to prevent a data breach every other week so i opted for 1password!
I regret the day i chose this slopy mess! 1password is comically bad in everything it does - Se valoró con 5 de 5por Usuario de Firefox 19510897, hace 6 meses
- Se valoró con 4 de 5por Chris Hayes, hace 6 mesesUsed 1Pass for about 7 years. Generally pretty solid, and usually the first to adopt new security practices. I like how smooth 2FA is.
The Firefox support could be better—the app always says "Firefox needs an update". Might be Snap related. Otherwise it functions fine. Sometimes the password autofill replaces fields that should be left alone.
1Pass uses a secondary password, called a "Secret Key", it's required when you use a new device. Be aware that you absolutely cannot lose this.
To the reviewer calling it "enshittification"—that's not what that word means. 1P has had secret key as long as I've used it (since 2019), that's long before Cory Doctorow even came up with that word.