Super Agent - Automatic cookie consent에 대한 리뷰
Super Agent - Automatic cookie consent 제작자: Super Agent
리뷰 48개
- 5점 만점에 1점Firefox 사용자 19414548 님, 9달 전Worked well for months, now starting to charge for it. using Consent-O-Matic instead witch is free and Open Source
- 5점 만점에 1점Firefox 사용자 19414301 님, 9달 전
- 5점 만점에 1점Firefox 사용자 13897011 님, 9달 전Used to be free and decided to swap to subscription based. Does not advertise that it is sub based.
- 5점 만점에 1점Firefox 사용자 19185659 님, 9달 전This USED to be a free plugin. Sadly, the developer has decided to chase money and remove all utility from the free version, with it only working "up to 3 times a day", otherwise asking for ~$10 per month. So, instead I will be uninstalling.
If you are reading this and haven't enabled automatic updates for plugins, then MAKE SURE TO DISABLE THEM!.
Louis Rossmann was right.개발자 답글
9달 전에 게시됨Hi, the extension costs 1$ a month. Not 10$. You can also downgrade if you don't want to pay the subscription. - 5점 만점에 1점Firefox 사용자 14559047 님, 9달 전Oh, thinking of making a funtune off "donations" then made very little, turns on the pay wall and blame others for not being nice.
How standard.
Leave.
Now.개발자 답글
9달 전에 게시됨Hi
Unfortunately we are two people working almost full time here, and for this to be viable we need to charge a subscription. I don't think 1$ is greedy or unfair, but if people don't like it they can downgrade or stop using it. Im also happy to offer you a subscription.
Regards 개발자 답글
9달 전에 게시됨Hi, we show a pop up once every two weeks. It seems pretty fair for a free version. The free version also works 3 times a day (also seems pretty fair but open to hear your thoughts). This extension takes a lot of time to keep updated as sites are constantly changing their cookie banners. I would be happy to offer you a free year.
It makes no sense to give me a one star review simply because you don't want to pay. You can just stop using it.
Feel free to get in touch hello@super-agent.com- Didn't do a ton for me to begin with, then popped up and asked for a subscription after saving me... 1.8 minutes of my time (apparently it kept track).
EDIT: Removed because it kept giving repeated popups. You aren't saving me time with cookies if I'm spending that time again dealing with your own popups. 개발자 답글
9달 전에 게시됨Hi, why is it a scam to charge for my work? This extension takes a lot of time to keep updated. I would be happy to offer you a free year. It makes no sense to give me a one star review simply because you don't want to pay. You can just stop using it.개발자 답글
10달 전에 게시됨Hi
We just tried to deploy a fix for youtube. Could you please check if it is still going? THanks!- ok, but still many sites where cookie popups are displayed, at least you can see in the dashboard that it does work on some sites and saves you some time and nerves
edit: after they unsolicitedly pay walled spammed me and opened ad popups I bought the lifetime license, didn't even bother to answer my E-Mail why they have no way to backup the whitelist db which should be an integral part to the app. Not even a manual backup, not even working when copy pasting yourself between Browsers. No Support Reply.
Get a free one, like EU Consetomatic, which does the same for absolutely free and not just 30 clicks per month or ad spam. - Privacy...
If you're going to anonymously do something you DON'T need a my email to set up an account.
You're either doing this as a public service or you're hiding something nefarious.
Just NO!
And there is it is - the first THREE a day are free after that, they're dipping in your pocket.
And this isn't a difficult thing to implement if the community built a database these annoying, non-standard dodges around the idiotic EU Cookie law. This is what happens when bureaucrats design a law without actually consulting with privacy experts (or any experts in regards of this example).
---- EDIT
"Hi, The extension is free for Firefox, it also doesn't require an email to set up. So this review simply makes no sense whatsoever."
That right... allow me to QUOTE the FAQ [URL REMOVED] highlight mine.
" We don’t store any personal data except for your *e-mail address* which we use only to verify your account and to synchronize your preferences across devices.
(So it does need an email...)
AND
"Super Agent is free for the first 3 pop ups a day. The “unlimited” version costs 1.19$€ a month or 11,99$€ a year. A 29.99$€ forever option will be available soon."
So someone is telling fibs, I'm simply quoting from the developer's OWN SITE.
AND
"We don’t store any personal data *except for your e-mail address* which we use only to verify your account and to synchronize your preferences across devices. "
AND
"... [I]nformation may be transferred to — and maintained on — computers located outside of Your state, province, country or other governmental jurisdiction where the data protection laws may differ than those from Your jurisdiction. Your consent to this Privacy Policy followed by Your submission of such information represents Your agreement to that transfer."
AND SO ON... Sure, this is boilerplate but it covers the company's rear, not ours.
And you don't need a central server to do this. Fingerprinting is quite sufficient to ID these Javascript devices, a central server is just a way to make sure we're "customers".
Three a day. Give me a break.개발자 답글
2년 전에 게시됨Hi, The extension is free for Firefox, it also doesn't require an email to set up. So this review simply makes no sense whatsoever. - 5점 만점에 1점Firefox 사용자 13588480 님, 2년 전Edit to address the developers' response: I can confirm that the performance hit mentioned below is NOT a conflict with uBlock Origin, as I made a point of disabling every extension I have, and individually reenabling them until I found the culprit. The performance issues were present with uBO still disabled, so I have to conclude that the fault does indeed lie with Super Agent. Not impressed.
THE ORIGINAL REVIEW
Had to uninstall as it made certain websites, and in particular YouTube, load like they're being powered by a netbook from circa 2010.
I'm also dubious at the prospect of sharing my data with a company, no matter how anonymised and altruistic, for the sake of preventing other companies from getting my data. It's just kicking the can down the road and doesn't eliminate the actual problem.
My recommendation? Just use a decent, preferably open source content blocker (eg uBlock Origin) and enable one of the built in "Cookie Notices" filter lists. Much more efficient, auditable, and doesn't involve sharing your data with a third party.개발자 답글
2년 전에 게시됨The issue you mention is probably caused by a conflict with uBlock as it seems to be the common denominator from people who complained about it.
Regarding data. We don't collect any data and our source code is reviewed often by the Chrome store, Firefox, Opera and Appstore. Apple is specially strict when it comes to privacy so it would not recommend our app if it wasnt 100% safe. - 5점 만점에 1점Firefox 사용자 18548978 님, 2년 전It basically bricked my firefox. Performance crawled to almost a halt. Even typing was super laggy. It's unfortunately not usable this way.
개발자 답글
2년 전에 게시됨Hi,
Could you email us some more info like you firefox version and if you use any other extensions? We have tens of thousands of users and we havent heard this complaint before. hello@super-agent.com
Thanks
Francisco - 5점 만점에 1점BlackDragonBE 님, 2년 전I was hopeful this would help me skip all those cookie banners. Instead, this add-on doesn't do anything. The icon hasn't been green once and I still get cookie banners on lots of websites. Just use uBlock Origin instead.
개발자 답글
2년 전에 게시됨Hi BlackDragonBE, could you email us at hello@super-agent.com? I would be happy to try and fix whatever bug you might have.
Thanks - 5점 만점에 1점Firefox 사용자 18277721 님, 2년 전I'm afraid I need to change my 5 star review to a 1 star. Extension was updated to only support a limited number of websites in the free plan and asks for money after a certain amount is reached.
- 5점 만점에 1점Firefox 사용자 17602889 님, 4년 전
- 5점 만점에 1점Firefox 사용자 17583546 님, 4년 전
개발자 답글
4년 전에 게시됨Hi Fernman, could you give us an example of a website where it is not working? I believe there might be something setup incorrectly.
Thanks