Overall it looks good and useful, however:

1) It doesn't explain why some bookmarks give an error
2) It returns as "errors" perfectly working bookmarks.
E.g. https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/ublock-origin/?src=search - It works fine but it's flagged as error
3) It should allow correcting multiple warnings/errors
4) Bookmarks paths are incomplete. This is very bad when trying to eliminate duplicates.

EDIT: that's it. After a couple of interactions it stopped working (I click check and nothing happens. Tried to close and reopen the tab, but it didn't solve. I'm going to uninstall it.

Another killer browser add on!

Works well, no duplicates or broken bookmarks anymore!

I can't figure how to use it. I had it search for "ERRORS". It found several, identified by a red dot in the HTML file it created, but my version does not have the delete all broken bookmarks thing to click on. Deleting them manually
would take a long time, but that does not work. I delete them in the HTML file, but they are still in my FireFox bookmarks.

It found about 5000 "Warnings" but I don't know what it is trying to warn me about.

I see in other review answers that I should be using version 2.0. How can I tell which version it is?

OK, now I can see it is version 2.0.1 by looking at the addons manager in firefox.
Is there a better way for me to reply other than editing my original comment?

I still cannot see a delete anything link. I took a screen capture. How can I sent it to you?

The Icon at the upper right says Hey. looks like there is a lot of cleanup to do, but does not show how to do that.

One of the best bookmark organizers.

Do its job and simple to use.

Working well on a large collection of bookmarks. I wish there would be a way to disable the confirmation dialog for each delete.

sorry, but yes i really think this is useless unless you can actually delete all those duplicates! like i said, i don't need the add-on to laboriously go through my own bookmarks and spend way too much time deleting them one by one. please add this essential aspect, then i'd be happy to change it from one start to five!

I had a similar experience as Loquacious1 and Anonymous user 436dc3. I installed Bookmarks Organizer and the first time I ran it, the three balls kept cycling. The second time I tried, it ran to completion. However, the check bookmarks remained greyed out and it was unresponsive.
I uninstalled the Add-on. I downloaded the Add-on again. I reinstalled. It runs fine.
Can't say that this was the first time that a reinstall cleared up the problem. Been around since the NCR 300 series...

Didn't try to work. Selected an option to check duplicates, broken links or missing titles and the button to start remained grayed out on each one.

Developer: You mean like this other review you were quick to discredit and call fake that says the same thing I just did? You seem to not accept that your add on doesn't work for everyone and blame the user! This is a sign of developer arrogance. Your app is worthless if it doesn't work and it does NOT.

"I've installed it and I have a screen with a little box with 3 options of analysing bookmarks.

There are three balls rippling back and fore from small to large which I presume is telling me summat's happening, but - nothing's happening.

Half an hour now and Zero Bookmarks in the box on the screen.

Am I missing something ?

There IS also a box in which the words "Check bookmarks" appears. It is greyed out and cannot be selected."

非常棒的一个扩展，从此不必担心有添加重复的书签而不自知了

I've installed it and I have a screen with a little box with 3 options of analysing bookmarks.

There are three balls rippling back and fore from small to large which I presume is telling me summat's happening, but - nothing's happening.

Half an hour now and Zero Bookmarks in the box on the screen.

Am I missing something ?

There IS also a box in which the words "Check bookmarks" appears. It is greyed out and cannot be selected.

Gibt kein besseres Addon, als dieses hier, tut was es soll! Danke.

It works this time since the update to 2.0.1
It could still use some additional features.
+Option to show only broken bookmarks, and not redirects.
+Option to show only redirects.
+Make it possible to remove folders, typically if the bookmark was the only one inside the folder and it was deleted, should be able to delete the folder too, without going to the Firefox Bookmarks view.

It's a great improvement over the older version I tried, keep up the good work.


reply: The checkboxes only appear if you are at the very top of the list. It would be better if you could make that part not scroll off the screen, as another layer or frame over the main frame.

Great add-on! Really cleans up and in a modern and usable fashion

Great extension! Congratulations!

thanks for your reply
i checked again and found two things:

1.
some working links were only reported as broken when the tracking protection in Firefox (disconnect.me / basic protection) is on; i know it was stated to set it of, but i thought since v.2.x the add-on would take care of that, sorry my fault
(just for info, these were some of the links: http://statcounter.com/ ; https://www.forbes.com/ ; http://www.ip-tracker.org/ ; https://twitter.com/ ; ...)

2.
still, with tracking protection off, there are some other working links reported as broken; it seems to occur when a site redirects to a localized version
(e.g.: bookmark = https://www.seagate.com reported as broken, but it opens https://www.seagate.com/be/nl/ ; also bookmark = https://www.microsoft.com/nl-be/default.aspx reported as broken, but it opens the same link) ; (note: a second run gave the same result)

hope this helps, thanks again for this very usefull extension, 5 stars now

========

about a month ago i had problems with the add-on hanging at the last bookmark check(s); all fixed now in version 2.x, works like a charm (also fast: 1600+ bookmarks scanned in a few minutes)

4 STARS ! (only reason for that one star less is that some working links are reported as broken (e.g. twitter) but i understand some false positives are nearly inevitable 'cause site settings, etc.)

big thanks to the developer

Repara los marcadores huerfanos, duplicados y rotos, siento que le falta más cosas como poder organizar los marcadores en carpetas o modificarlos de alguna forma, pero van por buen camino

works like a charm

Works very reliable since version 2. Still getting some weird duplicates about built in items (place:type and place:transition), which is probably a data integrity issue in my profile/sync data.