No YouTube comments에 대한 리뷰
No YouTube comments 제작자: Abdullah Diaa
리뷰 99개
- 5점 만점에 5점Firefox 사용자 13963950 님, 8년 전Works as described. It's great for watching videos about controversial topics; all of the arguing and attention-seeking in the comments is out of sight and out of mind. This extension keeps me in a good mood when I'm on Youtube.
- 5점 만점에 5점sinewalker 님, 8년 전Huray! no more comments, and optionally no other rubbish. And if you *must* see/add a comment for a video, just turn it back on temporarily from the drop-down menu. But only for helpful/instructional vids, not the NASA-flat-Earthers.
Doesn't stop ads, but there are other plugins to do that if you want. - 5점 만점에 5점Firefox 사용자 13995208 님, 8년 전No other addon than this one does what I was looking for, hidding the "up next" sidebar. Thanks whoever did this.
- 5점 만점에 5점Firefox 사용자 13894724 님, 8년 전
- Does what it advertises however I have a few gripes (this is feedback for 0.4pre5):
- after installing, it requires a page refresh to hide the comments
- there's no placeholder; sometimes I scroll down and forget the comments are blocked and wait for them to load (YouTube by default shows the same white space for a few seconds, even without the extension). Some text like "No comments here :)" would be helpful to remind me the comments are blocked
- also there's a typo :P "Prefrences" should be "Preferences" - Edit: Disregard the review below. Previously I gave this three stars, but the add-on hasn't been updated in two years, and the beta versions I mentioned below have been removed. There's no indication that the developer is taking any steps to fix the issues with this add-on. Therefore I've reduced my rating to one star.
Previous review:
Pretty nice! This makes YouTubing a much less chaotic experience! Only gripes for the current release are: 1) "Hide Related videos and sidebar" also hides the playlist sidebar when you're watching a video in a playlist; 2) "Hide comments" also makes it impossible to view playlists themselves.
The beta versions I've tried (0.4pre3–0.4pre5) fix the latter issue. However, they also move the preferences from a toolbar button to the add-ons page. For this type of add-on I think that's a poor decision. If I'm watching a video, and suddenly decide I want to see the sidebar, I don't want to have to pause the video, open a new tab, and navigate to preferences in order to do that, and then do the same thing again when I want to hide the sidebar again. This is the kind of add-on where you should be able to change preferences on the fly. - 5점 만점에 5점Firefox 사용자 13635276 님, 8년 전
- 5점 만점에 5점Firefox 사용자 13595430 님, 8년 전
- 5점 만점에 5점Firefox 사용자 13505877 님, 9년 전
- I *love* this add-on.
Unfortunately since Firefox Quantum came out I don't get it to work anymore :( I keep seeing those annoying comments which rarely contribute anything.
My specs: Windows 7 Ultimate, 64-bit, english version, Firefox Quantum (57.0 64-bit).
Have been using your add-on for months now and love it. Hope it will work again soon and if there's anything I'm doing wrong just let me now. Thanks!
EDIT: everything works fine again: no more useless comments. Thanks mate!
EDIT II: works fine on Windows 10 also :)개발자 답글
8년 전에 게시됨can you please try the beta version of the addon:
https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/no-youtube-comments/versions/beta - Your latest version is working well. (https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/no-youtube-comments/versions/beta) Now if I could get rid of the unwanted known "click-bait" channels that are in the video list to the right this thing will be back under MY control. ... Thank you for your work!
- 5점 만점에 5점illusivetech 님, 9년 전I can't imagine how many hours of my life this has saved me waiting for youtube pages to load.
개발자 답글
9년 전에 게시됨This will be fixed in the next version.
Update1: fixed and updaed on beta channel:
https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/no-youtube-comments/versions/beta
PLease try it and let me know if the problem persists.- 5점 만점에 4점Firefox 사용자 13269801 님, 9년 전Thank you for making this.
If I may suggest a feature: putting in an option to remove the 'enable/disable comments' button/keyboard shortcut you recently added, so that I'd have to go into the Add-On options if I REALLY want to see the comments. (I keep re-enabling comments thinking 'This is such an innocuous video that I'm sure there isn't any awful racist garbage in the comments THIS time' and 9 out of 10 times I'm wrong. :P)개발자 답글
9년 전에 게시됨Will move the button to settings and add option to disable browser icon and shortcut in the coming version.
Thanks for your reviiew :)
Update1: fixed and updaed on beta channel:
https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/no-youtube-comments/versions/beta
Update2: Please check out Version 0.4pre4 ,
https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/no-youtube-comments/versions/beta
More updates and fixes for your problem.
PLease try it and let me know if the problem persists. - 5점 만점에 5점Steve Jandali 님, 9년 전CleanTube is no longer supported but this is the ONLY best replacement for that extension. Thanks to Abdullah for this awesome extension!
개발자 답글
9년 전에 게시됨Not only i'll add the option back , but also with page action button to disable it for any page.
And a shortcut as well to make it almost instant.
Update 2: version released, try it now.
Update1: version 0.3 has been submitted with these features:
- add support to show/hide related videos.
- add support to show/hide recommended videos.
- add support to show/hide videos at the end playback.
- Add browser icon to update settings of the addon.
- Add page action to enable disable the addon manually for any page.
- add shortcut (Ctrl/Command+Shift+Y) to toggle the addon.
Stay tuned for the next update this week.- First of all, Abdullah, just wanted to say - Great add-on. I've been using this for ages.
I must rate it 3/5 though because I don't have the choice to instantly disable/enable comments like I used to (by pressing CTRL + SHIFT + A, choosing No YouTube Comments add-on and enabling/disabling it) and arguably the best feature of this little tool is missing. Related videos removal. I'm going to uninstall this for now, as I have no use for it anymore. But I do recommend it to those, who simply want comments to be removed from videos. It does what it says perfectly.
EDIT: For those who might think that comments can be disabled/enabled now by simply clicking on the disable/enable button in the Add-ons page, my main "beef" is with the removal of the "hide related videos" feature.
EDIT 2: I created a Firefox account specifically to leave this review. I rate it 10/5 for the response. You should definitely give me a donation link!개발자 답글
9년 전에 게시됨Hi Arthur,
I'll add these features to the next update of the addon.
Stay tuned for it :D
Update1: version 0.3 has been submitted with these features:
- add support to show/hide related videos.
- add support to show/hide recommended videos.
- add support to show/hide videos at the end playback.
- Add browser icon to update settings of the addon.
- Add page action to enable disable the addon manually for any page.
- add shortcut (Ctrl/Command+Shift+Y) to toggle the addon.
Update 2: version released, try it now.