After a decade of using KeePass and Bitwarden, I switched to Proton Pass six months ago (used on Windows, macOS, Ubuntu and my smartphone). I'm not going back!

What I like:
- In my experience, autofill is much more consistent than other managers (with only a few rare exceptions).
- As a paid user, the "hide-my-email" alias feature is a game-changer, no need for "+ addressing", and the integration with Proton Monitor came handy a few times already.
- The vault is type-rich. I knew the usual (logins, notes, and bank cards, passwords). I though the "Other" category was just for "Misc" entries, but recently discovered it has a lot of dedicated templates (API creds, DB creds, server creds, license keys, SSH keys, Wi-Fi networks, bank account details, crypto wallets, driving licenses, medical info, memberships, passports, loyalty programs, and SSN). It is much more organized than using generic "secure notes" for everything. It feels like an actual wallet.

The only pain point:
- The passkey experience (I'm a big advocate and user of passkeys) but found the implementation to be inconsistent. While the team is helpful, I’ve found that troubleshooting these issues is quite a time-sink for a user. It often requires testing across different browsers, clearing existing keys, and starting with fresh profiles, on various browsers, just to isolate the cause. As much as I want to help improve the tool, the "investigation" process is too tedious so I stopped after a few tickets. I'm hopeful this stabilizes soon so it can be as seamless and great as the rest of the app.

Overall, the extension is great, I definitely recommend it!

The extension is mostly fine. But I have twice now experienced that I have been logged out and need to log back in (by typing my very long password, which is stored elsewhere). There does not seem to be an easier way to log back in. Also, when being logged out, the settings in the extension also seem to be reset. This may happen when the extension/Firefox is updated.

Finally a trustable password manager. Autofill is lacking sometimes.

The app is good. It does what it promises. However, I've given 4 stars, not 5 because the UI can be made a little better.

Missing features such as username generator. UI/UX issues which I submitted to the support team. Bad management of the aliases for the backup.

Moved to ProtonPass from 1Password as I was already paying for the Proton suite. Overall, behaves decently. There's a few features I miss from 1Password, such as QR code scanning for OTP, and automatically recognizing a website's password requirements (although I prefer Proton's long text slugs, not all websites will accept them), and linking identities together, e.g. OAuth logins, or linking certain accounts to my entries for my YubiKeys. The integration with PassMail is *chef's kiss* though.

It's so nearly perfect.
I've come from Bitwarden and have been enjoying the whole Proton Suite, but Pass is missing 1 feature that i think should be mandatory in any password manager - When generating a password, let me pick a minimum amount required of Numbers and Special characters - With bitwarden i could ask it to make a pass containing at least 10 of each if i wanted.
This would easily be a 5 star if it had feature parity

works and is easy to use

On majority of websites when selecting text with a double tap and slide downwards/rightways, the website jumps (scrolls) up suddenly when the extension is enabled. Also there is no real autofill when the extension is unlocked, always have to select login entry.
(Firefox, Linux)

Functionality is mostly smooth and good, except for a few pages where user/pw fields are not correctly detected. An autosave-option for passwords created but not saved would be great. My main point for criticism is that the only ways to lock the addon are to either use an (only) 6-digit PIN, or to entirely log out of the proton account. I guess that the former option was provided to allow quick access, however, it is very unsafe in my opinion - I would prefer to have the choice to use e.g. longer PINs or an aaddon-password, etc. ...

Overall, Very good password manager, but it's not perfect. Sometimes it autofills wrong, doesn't pop up, or pops up in inconvenient or annoying ways, but what can you do?

Proton products are solid, and I use almost all of them.

autofill recognition can be improved a bit, otherwise perfect

Super gefällt mir gut dieser Password Manager. Nur manchmal wird er bei ausfüllen nicht angezeigt.