why is this an alternative to "private tab"? Cannot open a new tab in private mode!

Like other people already said, just open a new page in private, not a new tab in private mode.

if I wanted to open a new window i's do that myself... also, mozilla, please stop recommending this addon as a replacement for Private Tab, that's very pathetic

it just opens a new incognito window

does not work, opens a new private window not a new tab.
Firefox already does this without extensions.
We want a private tab not another bronser window in private mode.
useless extension

It doesn't add any value. A private tab option should be built-in in Firefox.

As other reviews indicated, doesn't open a new private tab or make current tab private. Ignore this extension

Nothing like Private Tab, it just opens a new window in private mode. Absolutely useless