Відгуки для Shinigami Eyes
Shinigami Eyes автор Shinigami Eyes
Відгук від spop
This app specifically says it is intended to help the transgender community. Things have recently changed where it now has chosen to exclude members of that community.
Trying to hold trans-femininity as the sole beacon to guide this project has hurt and left behind most of those it claimed to help, many of those who helped this tool grow.
If this app chooses to hurt all other genders for simply not worshiping the feminine, is it any better than a TERF tool? A group of transphobes who already villainize anything remotely masculine or non-feminine?
The transgender community, and more importantly the LGBTQ+ community as a whole, needs to accept that we may not all have the same personal definitions of gender, and that's okay. There will never be blanket terms to cover every nuance, we cannot limit ourselves, and we should never try to force others to exist within strict boxes or binaries.
Someone venting about their lived experience is not an attack on yours. It is petty and childish when you refuse to listen to your community and outright shun some groups like intersex individuals.
This add-on used to be one that brought us together, to help see others as part of a found family. If the future of it is now simply to be a club and to harm the reputation of others simply to only give oneself more attention, consider starting a vitriolic rant youtube channel instead.
Currently this app has been corrupted by transphobia. Yes, transgender people can be transphobic, especially when you choose to align your identity with exclusionary rhetoric and spout the same bioessentialism as TERFs and other bigots.
You really disappoint many of us, and should be doing better.
Trying to hold trans-femininity as the sole beacon to guide this project has hurt and left behind most of those it claimed to help, many of those who helped this tool grow.
If this app chooses to hurt all other genders for simply not worshiping the feminine, is it any better than a TERF tool? A group of transphobes who already villainize anything remotely masculine or non-feminine?
The transgender community, and more importantly the LGBTQ+ community as a whole, needs to accept that we may not all have the same personal definitions of gender, and that's okay. There will never be blanket terms to cover every nuance, we cannot limit ourselves, and we should never try to force others to exist within strict boxes or binaries.
Someone venting about their lived experience is not an attack on yours. It is petty and childish when you refuse to listen to your community and outright shun some groups like intersex individuals.
This add-on used to be one that brought us together, to help see others as part of a found family. If the future of it is now simply to be a club and to harm the reputation of others simply to only give oneself more attention, consider starting a vitriolic rant youtube channel instead.
Currently this app has been corrupted by transphobia. Yes, transgender people can be transphobic, especially when you choose to align your identity with exclusionary rhetoric and spout the same bioessentialism as TERFs and other bigots.
You really disappoint many of us, and should be doing better.
1 360 відгуків
- Оцінка 5 з 5від awawa, 13 годин томуDisregard the reviews from transmisogynists who are mad they or their fellow men's rights activists friends got marked red. Men are not oppressed on the basis of being men, never have been, never will be, and if you are a trans man actively de/misgendering yourself to try to cry that you're oppressed for your "female socialization" or whatever the hell, you have fallen for transmisogynistic dogwhistles. Do better. If you're on the fence, it's quite accurate, EVEN ON TUMBLR, and if you disagree with that, you are part of the problem. It's actually LESS accurate on other sites like Bluesky or Twitter because people will get marked green for saying "trans rights" once, but then they'll post dogwhistles and slurs that harm transfeminine people.
- Оцінка 1 з 5від confusedbug, день тому
- Оцінка 5 з 5від sara, 3 дні тому
- Оцінка 5 з 5від Користувач Firefox 17289853, 3 дні тому
- Оцінка 5 з 5від gigi, 4 дні томуthis add-on is actually rlly reliable if you fully comprehend *why* the people who are marked red/green are marked red/green. it's not about whether or not you're "nice" or are "normal," it's about whether or not you're safe for trans people to be around; specifically, *transfeminine* people, as they are the most vulnerable members of the trans community, and anyone who isn't safe for them shouldn't be considered "trans friendly." that's really all there is to it. useful extension!!! although i agree with people who say it would be nice to know why certain people were marked red/green, the context would be useful too
- Оцінка 5 з 5від Користувач Firefox 19830850, 4 дні тому
- Оцінка 5 з 5від Користувач Firefox 19829880, 4 дні тому
- Оцінка 5 з 5від oMorri, 4 дні тому
- Оцінка 5 з 5від Lavender, 8 днів тому
- Оцінка 5 з 5від Heather, 12 днів тому
- Оцінка 2 з 5від Talon, 13 днів томуuseful for news websites or social media users, completely useless for tumblr. normal people are often marked red while extremely aggressive people are sometimes marked green. discourse stances shouldnt be a measure on minority discrimination.
- Оцінка 5 з 5від Користувач Firefox 19809155, 15 днів томуthe 1-star reviews complaining about transmasc and intersex people getting marked red fail to consider WHY they get marked red (hating trans women)
- Оцінка 5 з 5від Користувач Firefox 17727821, 17 днів тому
- Оцінка 1 з 5від mystieneko, 18 днів томуlots of false flags, intersex people and trans men are almost always marked red while transmisandrists are marked green
- Оцінка 1 з 5від thevdsasff, 19 днів томуused to use this religiously after it first came out and at first it was genuinely useful. now after discovering i'm intersex i try to go to any community for the topic anywhere and everyone is marked red because our discussions of gender and sex don't 100% align with the mods views (which then gets called transmisogynist, when nobody is saying anything of the sort at all). this includes a disproportionate number of transfems, so the claims that simply being transfem will get you marked green are false. i have, however, seen people get marked within days of making an account somewhere *just because they are posting in intersex spaces*. so do with that information what you will. i personally never plan on using the extension again, i'll vet people myself
- Оцінка 1 з 5від Користувач Firefox 19803232, 19 днів томуAbysmal tool if you genuinely care about safety from transphobes. There is a mountain of examples where people who spew intersexist, exorsexist and antitransmasculine hatred 24/7 get to secure their "safe" marking while painting their trans siblings who won't stand for that as the real transphobes.
- Оцінка 1 з 5від frak, 19 днів томуThe Wikipedia page for gloves is marked green but only in spanish and asturian, this thing has no moderation whatsoever
It also says a lot that most of the recent 5 stars reviews are "you're just mad you're transmisogynistic and got flagged red LOL!" but never address the racism and the transphobes being flagged green complaints that they're responding to
I've also just noticed that the website got updated since when I first installed this addon and lists "theyfab" as a "community infighting" term when I've only ever heard it being said by TERFs. It's an enbyphobic slur and it's clearly transphobic - Оцінка 1 з 5від Користувач Firefox 17409768, 21 день томуThis extension- as many others have already pointed out- is no longer accurate or curated in any shape or form. I've used it for many years now, and I just keep catching false flags, especially on tumblr. Not worth the download in 2026
- Оцінка 5 з 5від Користувач Firefox 17939446, 22 дні тому
- Оцінка 5 з 5від Glossopetrae, 23 дні тому
- Оцінка 3 з 5від Spider-Man, 23 дні томуI wish there was a way to see why someone is marked as pro or anti trans. Like a quick description "Posts hateful comments on twitter" or "Regularly Advocates for trans rights during live streams"
- Оцінка 2 з 5від rani, 25 днів томуWhile at times very good, the community-sourced data on tumblr is prone to bad information from TERFs, false flags from petty infighting, and racism. Often, a trans-friendly and specifically transfeminine blog will be removed by community flagging for having affiliated with any other blog that does not subscribe to specifically radical transfeminist theory. The review process simply cannot keep up with the type of flagging system it has. I also still have concerns over how in the past, attempts to flag exorsexist and otherwise 'truscum' blogs were thrown out, and concerns about exorsexism as a form of transphobia were dismissed for potentially muddying the water in flagging transmisogynists. I'd honestly rate this app at a 3 were it not for its claims of being concerned with transphobia or anti-LGBTQ+ sentiments as a whole, when many reviewers and users will tell you that the extension was always only intended to report transmisogyny.