Pour utiliser ces modules complémentaires, vous devez télécharger Firefox.

Connexion
Icône du module

Critiques pour Wikiwand - Wikipedia Modernized

Wikiwand - Wikipedia Modernized par Wikiwand

3,8 étoiles sur 5
5
424
4
55
3
18
2
30
1
160
Avis de somna
par somna, il y a 5 ans
I don't think this is for me - it's so unlike Wikipedia. I did start to appreciate it after trying it for some time (I especially like the nav bar on the left), but I also encountered quite a lot of issues, so I think I'll stick to regular Wikipedia in the meantime.

- Infoboxes look terrible. Images are off-center and the infobox is too close to the body of the article.
- Tables are sometimes split up when they have multiple headers.
- I also think content in tables needs more horizontal padding.

Dark mode certainly needs more work.
- Some elements still have a light background and the light text on it is difficult to see.
- Links in dark mode are gray, which is absurd.
- The text is a bit too bright for me. Either a lighter background or darker text would be easier on the eyes.

- Page previews disappear too slowly when my cursor moves away from it. Waiting for one to go away gets annoying when I'm trying to read the article content.
- The font looks horrid when both italicized and bold.

I understand that some of these issues might be caused by Wikipedia's own architecture, but I'm opting out regardless.
687 notes
  • par LL, il y a 10 jours
    Disgusting that this once amazing app is now profiting on the free wikipedia. The developers should be ashamed of themselves. Uninstalling.
  • par Johannes Häusler, il y a un mois
    It really went down. what once was a nice skin for Wikipedia is now a really ducked up platform where Wikipedia does not profit. It DOES sell data and DOES have paid features so I dont think the extension is correctly disclosing such stuff, which is bad, especially in the EU
  • par Anvekeen, il y a un mois
    Can't believe how bad this add-on has become. Shameful
  • par Frkid, il y a un mois
    It was such a good add-on. Shame it turned into this.. whatever this is.
  • par sausje, il y a un mois
    Sadly this has gone down the drain. Forcing you to make an account just to sell the data for it.
  • par Utilisateur ou utilisatrice 19929310 de Firefox, il y a un mois
    That you would take something as pure as free, open-access education, slap a skin on it and try to harvest people's data shows what a bottom feeder this dev is.
  • par Silvio, il y a un mois
    Forces you to create an account for no apparent reason. Disregard old 5 star reviews, this is trash now. Ensh*ttification at its finest.
  • par Manuel Isaias, il y a un mois
    This used to be one of the best. Sad ending.
  • par Recharger, il y a un mois
    Finally reached my breaking point with this extension which used to be amazing. Making me register is the last straw. I'll miss the good old days!
  • par DadManBlues, il y a 2 mois
    The latest version forces mandatory registration and sign-in. I don't see the point in that at all. I have around 2 dozen Ff plugins in use - none of them forces registration.

    I'm sorry, I'll miss you.
  • par Utilisateur ou utilisatrice 14209344 de Firefox, il y a 2 mois
  • par simurq, il y a 3 mois
    Newer versions of the addon are getting worse with every release. AI addition is what ruins it, in my opinion. Standard Wikipedia looks prettier and loads easier without the addon's distractors.
  • par Sushiimi, il y a 3 mois
    Wikiwand has been great for years but unfortunately, as outlined by many other reviews, has gone downhill after shoehorning in excessive AI integrations and simply becoming non-functioning for basic usage.
  • par NoxlynU, il y a 3 mois
    The old design was really modern and better than Wikipedia's, and there were many customization options.
    However, the new design is way less confortable and customizable.
    The only addition is intrusive AI.
    Wikipedia is better without Wikiwand now.
  • par huianxin, il y a 5 mois
    Like others said, used to be good. Now there's some useless new features. Stop spamming AI in my face. And worst of all, it stopped working! Keeps displaying "Article not found", making it utterly unusable. Way to ruin what was once a great app.
  • par Utilisateur ou utilisatrice 19567302 de Firefox, il y a 7 mois
  • par Elfirya, il y a 7 mois
  • par Howar31, il y a 8 mois
    too much useless features. settings are not saved keep resetting. and also ads
  • par Rikko, il y a 8 mois
    Не работает в РФ.
  • par Haltarys, il y a 9 mois
    The extension used to be good but now they're pushing users to subscribe, don't follow dark mode by default anymore (it resets every couple of days or so), and push the AI tab too much.

    (And apparently, it has way too much ads, which I don't see because I use an ad blocker anyway)
  • par Utilisateur ou utilisatrice 19053100 de Firefox, il y a 10 mois
    Used to be really good, now it's infested with ads (ON A WIKIPEDIA SKIN, a notably ad free site) and AI bullshit everywhere, asking for a subscription. It also automatically blocks access to actual wikipedia, by automatically rerouting every article to their skin of it. No even entering the wikipedia website manually can you there with this extension installed. Where can i just get this extension, but how it was 2 or 3 years ago?
  • par Utilisateur ou utilisatrice 19391462 de Firefox, il y a 10 mois
    was a good addon until constant ai ads
  • par Ppercya, il y a 10 mois
    Use it constantly — no issues at all
  • par Utilisateur ou utilisatrice 19114790 de Firefox, il y a un an
  • par Sciky, il y a un an
    This used to be a great extension, but now it's a bloatware full of ads for its AI, what a shame