Beoardielingen foar 1Password: Password Manager
1Password: Password Manager troch 1Password Devs
Wurdearringen foar Firefox-brûker 15273621
Wurdearring: 2 fan 5
troch Firefox-brûker 15273621, 7 jierren lynI really like 1Password as a service, but this addon is severly lacking. The overall functionality is there, but several small hiccups make it rather cumbersome to use.
1) It displays a little icon in form fields that you can press to access its functionality. When 1Password is locked (after inactivity) clicking this icon does not in fact open 1password, but displays the message "use ctrl+period to open password". Why would I click the icon if opening 1password wasn't already what I wanted?! Maybe this is a security feature, I don't know? But then make the icon reflect whether 1pw is currently locked or not, so I don't waste time clicking this icon when most of the time doing so achieves absolutely nothing.
2) The 1pw dropdown interferes with firefox' native dropdown in annoying ways. After about one year of usage I still haven't figured out what makes the 1pw dropdown appear and what not.
3) Sometimes when the 1pw dropdown opens up, it makes the whole page jump/move vertically. What's that about?
There are other glitches like this depending on how sites are programmed. Sometimes it's 1pw filling in the fields that makes the whole page jump too.
4) As others have said: It would make a lot more sense if a new password could be saved AFTER the sign up process on a site.
5) There is no way to customize the password generator as there is for exampe in the Android app. If the suggested password doesn't meet the site's criteria you're out of luck using the generator.
1) It displays a little icon in form fields that you can press to access its functionality. When 1Password is locked (after inactivity) clicking this icon does not in fact open 1password, but displays the message "use ctrl+period to open password". Why would I click the icon if opening 1password wasn't already what I wanted?! Maybe this is a security feature, I don't know? But then make the icon reflect whether 1pw is currently locked or not, so I don't waste time clicking this icon when most of the time doing so achieves absolutely nothing.
2) The 1pw dropdown interferes with firefox' native dropdown in annoying ways. After about one year of usage I still haven't figured out what makes the 1pw dropdown appear and what not.
3) Sometimes when the 1pw dropdown opens up, it makes the whole page jump/move vertically. What's that about?
There are other glitches like this depending on how sites are programmed. Sometimes it's 1pw filling in the fields that makes the whole page jump too.
4) As others have said: It would make a lot more sense if a new password could be saved AFTER the sign up process on a site.
5) There is no way to customize the password generator as there is for exampe in the Android app. If the suggested password doesn't meet the site's criteria you're out of luck using the generator.
Antwurd ûntwikkeler
7 jierren lyn pleatstThank you for sharing! I’m happy to address the issues you mentioned.
1. I appreciate this feedback. The Ctrl+Period shortcut does open the 1Password X pop-up, but I agree that it’d be nice to have the ability to unlock 1Password X directly from the inline menu.
2. It sounds like you’re wanting to use Firefox’s autofill feature as well as 1Password. They can interfere, but we do have a way to disable the 1Password X inline menu if you’d prefer. To do so, turn off the “offer to fill and save passwords” option on the 1Password X settings page.
3. I haven’t heard of any reports of this, so I’d love to know when/where that happens. Do you experience it only on a certain website or does it happen on all sites? Please let us know at support+x@1password.com.
4. This request is on our radar, although determining whether a user has successfully signed into a site has given us some trouble in the past. In the end, we took the most reliable approach to save a Login before moving on to the next page. Not only that, but we need to capture the credentials on the page before moving onto the next, and if we don’t offer to save until moving onto the next page, those credentials need to be stored somewhere. I wouldn’t agree that’s the most secure option, but it’s something we’ll keep in mind as we build future versions of 1Password.
5. We do offer a full-featured password generator within the 1Password X pop-up. To get there, you’ll want to click the + button then click Password Generator. Here’s a video that shows how to access it: https://s3.amazonaws.com/com-agilebits-users/kaitlyn/password_generator.mp4
These are fantastic pieces of feedback, so I’m really glad you shared them. If there’s anything else we can help you with, please don’t hesitate to reach out via email.
1. I appreciate this feedback. The Ctrl+Period shortcut does open the 1Password X pop-up, but I agree that it’d be nice to have the ability to unlock 1Password X directly from the inline menu.
2. It sounds like you’re wanting to use Firefox’s autofill feature as well as 1Password. They can interfere, but we do have a way to disable the 1Password X inline menu if you’d prefer. To do so, turn off the “offer to fill and save passwords” option on the 1Password X settings page.
3. I haven’t heard of any reports of this, so I’d love to know when/where that happens. Do you experience it only on a certain website or does it happen on all sites? Please let us know at support+x@1password.com.
4. This request is on our radar, although determining whether a user has successfully signed into a site has given us some trouble in the past. In the end, we took the most reliable approach to save a Login before moving on to the next page. Not only that, but we need to capture the credentials on the page before moving onto the next, and if we don’t offer to save until moving onto the next page, those credentials need to be stored somewhere. I wouldn’t agree that’s the most secure option, but it’s something we’ll keep in mind as we build future versions of 1Password.
5. We do offer a full-featured password generator within the 1Password X pop-up. To get there, you’ll want to click the + button then click Password Generator. Here’s a video that shows how to access it: https://s3.amazonaws.com/com-agilebits-users/kaitlyn/password_generator.mp4
These are fantastic pieces of feedback, so I’m really glad you shared them. If there’s anything else we can help you with, please don’t hesitate to reach out via email.
1.793 beoardielingen
- Wurdearring: 5 fan 5troch Firefox-brûker 18408599, 8 dagen lyn
- Wurdearring: 5 fan 5troch Firefox-brûker 14077629, 12 dagen lyn
- Wurdearring: 5 fan 5troch Firefox-brûker 20061024, 16 dagen lyn
- Wurdearring: 2 fan 5troch dan, ien moanne lyn
- Wurdearring: 5 fan 5troch Firefox-brûker 20038309, ien moanne lynAmazing! Works great and I never have any issues. I'm so glad I switched over from Lastpass. And they had a super easy migration which let me copy over all of my passwords from Lastpass in one click, highly recommend!
- Wurdearring: 5 fan 5troch manos34, ien moanne lyn
- Wurdearring: 5 fan 5troch manos34, 2 moannen lyn
- Wurdearring: 5 fan 5troch ProfanityHumanity, 2 moannen lynMassive convenience. It's extremely useful.
- Wurdearring: 5 fan 5troch Firefox-brûker 19943156, 3 moannen lyn
- Wurdearring: 5 fan 5troch theBEERDSMAN, 3 moannen lyn
- Wurdearring: 5 fan 5troch Joshua, 3 moannen lynThis is an awesome plugin, shame about how slow Mozilla is with adding new versions.
At the time of writing this, I can only get version 8.12.4 and 1Password have already released 8.12.12 two weeks ago. The version Mozilla have is close to 3 months old.... - Wurdearring: 2 fan 5troch Christopher, 3 moannen lyn
- Wurdearring: 1 fan 5troch Firefox-brûker 13261523, 4 moannen lyn1Password does several things well, especially in Google Chrome. However, in Firefox, the 1Password experience is genuinely problematic and highly unreliable.
The most serious issue is that it does not work properly with HTTP Basic Authentication pop-up login windows. In Firefox, I often have to click multiple times and even navigate back in the browser before eventually receiving a different error message, after which the login may finally work. This issue does not occur in Google Chrome.
This has been going on for months. I pay for an expensive subscription, but I do not expect to renew it unless this problem is properly resolved. For my work, I use a very large number of HTTP Basic Authentication links with login pop-ups, and this simply has to function correctly. At the moment, I am forced to click repeatedly or switch to Google Chrome just to get basic functionality.
Support from 1Password has also been extremely slow. It often takes several days to receive a response, which is very disappointing.
My subscription runs until November 2026, but I am already considering alternatives. That is unfortunate, because 1Password does many things very well. However, when it comes to Firefox, the overall experience has been a major disappointment. Judging by the large number of negative comments here, I am clearly not the only one experiencing this.
Sidenote: also the 1Password application for Android phone has issues; it reports 9 out of 10 times, that it has no connection, so all passwords I am adding, do not show up on my desktop. #fail #1password - Wurdearring: 1 fan 5troch Firefox-brûker 19822537, 4 moannen lynThe plugin is significantly slowing my browser, tested my suspicions on a browser benchmark site and speed score went from 8 with the plugin on and 30 with it disabled (nothing else changed)
- Wurdearring: 1 fan 5troch aaFn, 5 moannen lynCrap application, intrusive, pop ups all the time. Obscure ways to configure, tries to be "intelligent" but of course is not and then hides its internal "guessed" configuration, much less flexible and customizable than Keepass.
When imposed by companies, have to use it, else avoid like hell ! (and do not use it for personal side, your data is on a cloud and a company which is not trustable !) - Wurdearring: 1 fan 5troch Firefox-brûker 5951631, 5 moannen lynIf you already have 1password account, that has some kind of order, this extension will ruin the order you created by duplicating records you created with records called "Sign in" or something.
- Wurdearring: 4 fan 5troch Garett, 5 moannen lynWorks well for the most part, but it can get annoying when I don't want to save a particular account used for log-ins. The pop-up should have a "No, and don't ask me again" option so that it doesn't come up every time.
- Wurdearring: 5 fan 5troch Firefox-brûker 19433288, 6 moannen lyn
- Wurdearring: 3 fan 5troch Liang, 6 moannen lynIt works but introduces severe performance degradation, you can prove this by going on browserbench and running the test with it disabled and compare
- Wurdearring: 1 fan 5troch syldub, 6 moannen lynNul. Intrusif au possible. Je dois utiliser 1Password car mon entreprise l'impose... mais KeePass est largement plus adapté. On a sans arrêt des popup au cours de la navigation. Dommage, les options qui auraient pu être intéressantes pour être moins pollué ne sont pas paramétrables. Insupportable. Désinstallé direct.