I was very excited for this one, but using it since it launched has been nothing but bad. Terrible integration, also if I get an sms code through my Mac on messages, I now has to physically type it in, instead of my mac knowing the code... nothing about this extension is good.

Need to re-authenticate very often which is extremely annoying

doesnt work on windows

It needs to be working on Windows to be actually useful.

Latest update fixes the major problem, which is that this used to not actually work in Windows :) It does now. The behaviour you see on Firefox for MacOS is replicated under Windows, giving the same experience you get with Edge (if you hate yourself enough to use Microsoft's browser).

Four stars instead of five because it seems incapable of handling one-time codes for MFA, so you'll still need to dual-wield either your phone or the iCloud for Windows Passwords app - but for most things it's now a seamless experience.

Seems to work well. Wish it didn't auto open the password fill modal when I load a page and it seems like that modal and the default firefox modal don't play well together. Room for improvement for sure, but nice to have the integration none the less

一直在考虑用第三方的，现在有了官方的，可放心了，

Didn't work on Windows Firefox :/

Things work reasonable well after deleting the old extension and reinstalling.

It's not quite as well integrated as passwords are in Safari (no password generation, that I can see at least), but it gets the job done.


A few notes:
* it doesn't display the title of the password in the dropdown when allowing you to select which one to use, only the username + the first website associated with it.

* Using Grafana, when clicking on a dropdown selector for a variable with a large number of selectable options (1,000+), the page often becomes completely unresponsive, and I'll get a banner telling me that "*iCloud Passwords" is slowing down Firefox. To speed up your browser, stop that extension." after about 10 seconds [0]. (FF 133.0.3 (aarch64), Passwords Version 1.2 (20620.1.16.11.8), Extension 3.0.6, about 400 stored Passwords)

* Apple really needs to clarify the lineage of the extension on the homepage. It's confusing looking through older comments and seeing a developer with seemingly no association to Apple responding to issues. I had to verify through news articles that they had actually acquired the extension.

[0] Interestingly, I stopped using Safari because poor performance when using this same web app made it unusable.

Instead of writing an original review, I'm just going to copy and paste what somebody else wrote a week ago, because it is exactly my experience: "Using Firefox 133.0.3 on Sequoia 15.1.1. Pop-up appears but nothing happens beyond that. Doesn't fill in password info."

Originally this add-on was working not great but good enough for using iCloud passwords. It was written by someone not working for Apple. Then it was officially adopted by Apple. Since then it no longer works reliable.

However, the add-on by the original author is still available on Github and works fine. I hope Apple is seriously interested in supporting Firefox and has not just adopted the add-on to destroy it as an benefit for Safari.

Funktioniert nicht in Firefox

Yani yıl olmuş kaç hala eksikleri var. Örneğin Windows üzerindeki firefox tarayıcımda kullanamıyorum.

Keeps on slowing down the browser when looking at pages like Reddit and bringing up the prompt to kill the extension. It works for the most part but it still needs TLC.

The app slows down websites, prompts me to stop the extension. This makes the website completely unusable. I haven't found this useful at all since i've installed it and it's caused more harm than good so far. I hope this extension gets improved in the future.

Very handy, and I'm super glad iCloud Passwords has finally come to Firefox. However, on pages with many textboxes, it slows the page to a crawl when entering text (even when they're not passwords!)

There are a few other bugs (needing to use 2FA every time Firefox re-opens in order to autofill), but overall very helpful.

Most of the functions are gone as it prompts you to open passwords app on
Macbook air